On 29 and 30 January 2026, the Swiss Federal Tax Administration (SFTA) published the new circulars on the tax-deductible interest rates for intra-group advances and loans in Swiss francs as well as in foreign currencies. [1] As in previous years, the overall principles remain unchanged; however, the SFTA has adjusted the interest rates in specific areas.

 

MINIMUM INTEREST RATES FOR ADVANCES TO SHAREHOLDERS OR RELATED PARTIES

For advances to shareholders or related parties, the SFTA interest circulars distinguish between equity- and debt-financed loans, as well as between loans in Swiss francs and foreign currencies.

The minimum required margin for debt-financed CHF loans is 0.5% (for loans below CHF 10 million) or 0.25% (for loans exceeding CHF 10 million). For loans in foreign currencies, a margin of at least 0.5% must be maintained; however, the interest rate must not fall below the level specified in the circular for the currency at hand.

The updated interest rate circulars lead to the following changes compared to the previous year:

 

MAXIMUM INTEREST RATES FOR ADVANCES FROM SHAREHOLDERS OR RELATED PARTIES

Different maximum interest rates apply depending on the type of loan from shareholders or related parties. For loans in Swiss francs, the following interest rates apply:

For operating loans in foreign currencies, the same spread can be applied as in the SFTA circular on tax-deductible interest rates for advances or loans in Swiss francs (up to an equivalent of CHF 1 million: 2.75% and 2.25%, respectively; above an equivalent of CHF 1 million: 0.75% and 0.50%, respectively).

The spread refers to the difference between the maximum permissible interest rate in Swiss francs for the respective loan and the minimum required margin for loans to shareholders or related parties. The sum of the defined foreign currency interest rate and the spread results in the following maximum interest rates for advances from shareholders or related parties:

 

TAX-RECOGNIZED INTEREST RATES AS ‘SAFE HAVEN’ RATES

In the context of interest on intra-group loans under Swiss tax law, the SFTA interest circulars can be used as a «safe haven». Companies operating within these ranges can generally assume that the tax authorities will consider it commercially justified and therefore accept it. However, a taxpayer is not bound to the published interest rates and may deviate from them if needed, whereby it must be proven that the interest rate applied is consistent with the arm's length principle. In this regard, the Federal Supreme Court issued a controversial ruling in summer 2024, stating that the SFTA «safe haven» interest rates no longer apply if a taxpayer deviates from these rates and bases their calculations on the arm’s length principle. In such cases, the tax authorities are to apply a lower or higher interest rate, provided it complies with the arm’s length principle [2] , with the burden of proof resting on the tax authority. Whether this ruling of the Federal Supreme Court will be strictly applied in practice remains to be seen. It is expected that the tax authorities will only undertake the effort to determine the “actual” arm’s length interest rate in particularly significant cases and will in general continue to rely on the «safe haven» rates as a correction measure.

As mentioned, it is possible to deviate from the interest rates published in the interest rate circulars, provided that the interest rate complies with the arm's length principle. It is recommended that compliance with the arm's length principle be properly documented. In this context, it should be noted that an offer from banks or other financial institutions is generally not sufficient.

CONSEQUENCES OF CORRETIONS BY THE TAX AUTHORITIES

If the agreed interest rates deviate from the published rates and are not at arm’s length, the exceeding part qualifies as a deemed dividend. For the paying company a deemed dividend will lead to an adjustment for corporate income tax purposes (partially negating deductibility of paid interest). In addition, the company owes the withholding tax of 35% on the deemed dividend. Withholding tax must be passed on to the beneficial owner of the dividend retroactively. Failure to do so can lead to a so-called hundred-percent adjustment, which may result in a withholding tax of approximately 54%. In the case of a deemed dividend, the withholding tax can regularly constitute a definitive charge if reimbursement is partially or fully denied.

TAX-RECOGNIZED INTEREST RATES AS ‘SAFE HAVEN’ RATES

In light of the adjusted interest rates, taxpayers should generally review loans between related parties and, in particular, in intra-group loan relationships. This applies not only to new financing arrangements but also to ongoing loans. If the loan agreements are already structured in a way that the applicable interest rate is based on the ‘safe haven’ rates, the interest payments should be adjusted accordingly. If the interest rate according to the loan agreement is not linked to the SFTA rates, a contractual adjustment of the rates should be considered or – without adjustment – evidence that the rate deviating from the SFTA rates complies with the arm’s length principle should be prepared.

Especially in the case of cross-border financing, larger credit volumes, or loans in foreign currencies, a detailed analysis is advisable to avoid negative tax impact, in particular in the form of deemed dividends with corporate income tax and withholding tax consequences.

The 2026 interest circulars, as expected, do not change the general principles. Companies using the ‘safe haven’ rates continue to benefit from administrative simplification. Those who deviate from the published rates or maintain complex financing structures should carefully review and document the appropriateness of the interest rates.

[1] The circular letters regarding the interest rates recognized for tax purposes are available at this LINK .
[2] Please also see our blog post dated August 23, 2024.

As of 1 January 2026, various tax-relevant legislative and regulatory changes came into effect in Switzerland. Additional provisions will follow over the course of the year. The reforms largely reflect a trend towards increased transparency and the expansion of international tax information exchange. The most important changes are summarized below.

 

AUTOMATIC EXCHANGE OF INFORMATION ON CRYPTO ASSETS (CARF) AND ADJUSTMENTS TO THE COMMON REPORTING STANDARDS (CRS)

As of 1 January 2026, Switzerland has established the domestic legal framework for the implementation of the automatic exchange of information on crypto assets. To this end, the Federal Act and Ordinance on the International Automatic Exchange of Information in Tax Matters (AEOIA / AEOI Ordinance) were amended. The new reporting framework is based on the OECD’s Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework (CARF).

The international treaty basis [1] has not yet been ratified. The National Council’s Economic Affairs Committee (WAK-N) suspended discussions in November 2025, mainly due to delayed implementation in key markets and unresolved interpretive issues at the OECD level. Parliamentary consideration is expected to resume in 2026. If approved, information exchange could begin on 1 January 2027, with the first data exchange likely occurring in 2028.

In parallel, adjustments to the OECD Common Reporting Standard (CRS) have been decided, particularly concerning:

  • inclusion of digital payment instruments,
  • expansion of reportable assets to include hybrid and tokenized instruments,
  • clarifications on due diligence obligations and technical harmonisation.

The Swiss Federal Council has decided that the CRS amendments relating to crypto assets will also apply only from 2027.

Further information can be found at this LINK

INTERNATIONAL AUTOMATIC EXCHANGE OF SALARY DATA

Double taxation agreements (DTAs) or related supplementary agreements with Italy and France contain special rules on taxation of cross-border workers and teleworking. These rules are complemented by an automatic exchange of salary data.

Implementing the automatic exchange of information requires new legal provisions under Swiss law. The Federal Act on the International Automatic Exchange of Information on Salary Data (AIALG) provides the necessary domestic legal basis. The Act specifically regulates:

  • employer reporting obligations,
  • responsibilities of Cantonal Tax Authorities and the Swiss Federal Tax Administration (SFTA),
  • data protection and procedural matters.

The referendum period for the AIALG expired unused on 15 January 2026. The Act is expected to come into force no earlier than 1 May 2026.

Under this LINK you will find further information on this topic.

TRANSPARENCY REGISTER AND AMENDMENTS TO THE ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING ACT

The new Federal Act on the Transparency of Legal Entities and the Identification of Beneficial Owners (LETA) aims to increase transparency of corporate structures in Switzerland and to more effectively combat the misuse of legal entities. In the future, legal entities must not only identify their beneficial owners but also report them to a federal transparency register. The transparency register is, in principle, not publicly accessible.

A beneficial owner is a natural person who directly or indirectly, alone or with others, controls a company. Control through ownership exists, in particular, when a person holds at least 25% of the capital or voting rights. Control by other means exists when a person can exert a significant legal or factual influence over the company. Reporting obligations also apply to certain foreign companies with a connection to Switzerland.

The purpose of the transparency register is to provide law enforcement and administrative authorities with targeted access to reliable information, to more effectively combat money laundering, asset concealment, corruption, tax fraud, and tax evasion. Notably, the SFTA and cantonal tax authorities will also have access to the register. In particular, in residence and tax domicile procedures, the new transparency is expected to reduce the information asymmetry between taxpayers and tax authorities.

In parallel, the scope of the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA) is being expanded. In the future, certain advisers – in addition to financial intermediaries – will also be subject to AMLA’s due diligence and reporting obligations. This includes, in particular, individuals professionally involved in real estate transactions or in the structuring of non-operational legal entities.

The referendum period for the LETA and the AMLA amendments expired unused on 15 January 2026. The corresponding legislative and regulatory provisions are expected to come into force in the second half of the year 2026.

Under this LINK you will find more information.

GLOBE INFORMATION RETURN (GIR) AND INTERNATIONAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE

In the context of the OECD minimum taxation rules (Pillar 2), the GloBE Information Return (GIR) has been introduced in Switzerland. To avoid multiple filings, an international agreement allows the automatic exchange of this information between countries.

As of 1 January 2026, corresponding ordinance amendments came into effect. They specifically regulate:

  • submission procedures with the SFTA ,
  • international exchange of information,
  • the use of data by cantonal authorities.

Additionally, on 16 December 2025 the Council of States approved the multilateral agreement on the exchange of GloBE information. Entry into force is expected no earlier than 1 July 2026.

Further information can be found at this LINK

EXTENSION OF THE LOSS CARRYFORWARD PERIOD FROM 7 TO 10 YEARS, EXPECTED FROM 2028

On 19 December 2025, Parliament passed the Federal Act on the Extension of the Loss Carryforward Period. This legislative amendment extends the previous loss carryforward period for self-employed individuals and legal entities from 7 to 10 years. The new rules apply to federal direct tax as well as cantonal and municipal taxes.

The extended carryforward period applies to tax losses arising from the 2020 tax period onwards. Losses from earlier periods remain subject to the previous 7-year carryforward period.

Since losses are generally verified at the time of their utilisation, it is advisable to retain relevant business documents and accounting records until the assessment of the tax period in which the loss is applied becomes final. Due to the newly provided 10-year carryforward period, it may occur that, at the time of offsetting, the statutory minimum retention period for accounting records has already expired. Voluntary extended retention is therefore recommended.

The referendum period lasts until 17 April 2026. Entry into force is expected on 1 January 2028, provided no referendum is called.

CONCLUSION

The tax changes in 2026 represent another step towards greater transparency and international coordination. Companies, financial intermediaries, and advisers face expanded reporting, due diligence, and compliance obligations. Early engagement with the new rules is crucial to limit legal risks and administrative burdens.

[1] Addendum to the Multilateral Competent Authority Agreement on the Automatic Exchange of Information on Financial Accounts and to the Multilateral Competent Authority Agreement on the Automatic Exchange of Information under the Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework.

Tax-free capital gains are attractive for investors and entrepreneurs in Switzerland. However, what appears to be an advantage at first glance can turn out to be a tax trap. Under certain circumstances, capital gains can be classified as income - with significant tax and social security consequences. This article shows what shareholders and investors should be aware of.

Tax-free capital gains or taxable income? What sharehold-ers need to be aware of

Private capital gains are generally tax-free in Switzerland - a significant advantage for investors and entrepreneurs. However, a recent ruling by the Federal Supreme Court [1] highlights the com-plexity of distinguishing between tax-free capital gains and taxable income. This ambiguity can result in unexpected tax consequences under specific circumstances. The matter becomes par-ticularly complex when commercial securities trading or a self-employed activity is suspected. If a capital gain qualifies as taxable income, it may result in significant and often unanticipated income tax and social security contributions. This article highlights the main issues.

PRIVATE ASSETS VS. BUSINESS ASSETS

The realization of a tax-free capital gain preconditions the (profitable) sale of private assets. By contrast, gains from the sale of business assets are in any case subject to income tax and social security contributions.

The assumption of business assets presupposes the exercise of a self-employed activity. If no such activity is carried out, no business assets can be assumed against the will of the taxpayer, meaning that all assets held constitute private assets from which tax-free capital gains can be generated. If a taxable person – consciously or unconsciously – is self-employed, it must be determined on a case-by-case basis whether an asset is to be classified as private or business asset. This depends on the individual circumstances, whereby the so-called technical-economic function of the asset in question plays a central role. In this context, it should be noted that the holding and management of assets themselves – be it securities, real estate or other stores of value – could, under certain circumstances, constitute (part-time) self-employment. The intention to actually be self-employed is not decisive in this respect.

SELF-EMPLOYMENT

The term self-employment is not defined by law, but all income from a trade, business, liberal profession or other self-employed activity is subject to tax. In practice, the term is interpreted broadly. Accordingly, all profits from activities that go beyond the simple management of private assets are considered taxable income. This also includes capital gains from the sale or use of business assets.

The determination of whether a person is self-employed hinges on the specific circumstances of each individual case. The Federal Supreme Court takes the following indicators into account:

  • Systematic or planned way of proceeding
  • Frequency of transactions
  • Short period of ownership
  • Close relation to the professional activity of the taxable person
  • Use of own specialist knowledge
  • Use of substantial external funds to finance the transactions
  • Reinvestment of profits generated

Each of these indicators may be sufficient together with others but may also be sufficient on their own to assume self-employment. The fact that typical elements of self-employment are not fulfilled in individual cases can be compensated for by other elements that are particularly pro-nounced. The individual aspects may not be considered in isolation and can also vary in intensi-ty. The decisive factor is that the activity as a whole is aimed at earning income.

The assessment of all the circumstances without a clear hierarchy of the listed indications makes it difficult to assess in individual cases whether or not self-employment is to be assumed. The fact that even a single indication can be sufficient if it is particularly pronounced shows that the hurdle for assuming self-employment is relatively low. This – of course – is particularly relevant when the activity is profitable.

TECHNICAL-ECONOMIC FUNCTION

The distinction between private and business assets is made according to the technical and eco-nomic function of the asset in question. This refers to the connection of the asset with a possi-ble self-employed activity.

A sufficiently close connection is generally deemed to exist if an asset is objectively recogniza-ble as being used for business purposes or actually serves the self-employed activity. The ques-tion is therefore whether an asset (e.g. a shareholding) serves to increase income or reduce expenses of the self-employed business activity. If a participation grants significant influence over a company in the same or a related industry as the owner's own company, this is consid-ered an indication that the participation qualifies as business asset. This assumption is in general confirmed, if the participation generates mandates for the owner's own company. This is the case, for example, with an architect who holds shares in real estate companies and acquires ar-chitectural contracts for his own architecting company from these companies.[2]

However, it is important to note that not only shareholdings in the same sector can qualify as business assets. Shareholdings outside the same sector can also be regarded as business as-sets if they are suitable for usefully expanding or supplementing the field of activity of the parent company or for diversifying business activities. In any case, the decisive factor is the intention of the person concerned to use the participation specifically to improve the operating result of their own company or its opportunities on the market.

Against this background, the Federal Supreme Court recently ruled [3] that self-employed lawyers are not prohibited from holding additional securities of their clients as private assets. The Feder-al Supreme Court thus protected the position of the taxpayer and upheld his appeal. In its rea-soning, the court stated that the lawyer's activities, repeated advice, investment activities and membership of the board of directors were not in themselves sufficient evidence to classify the shareholding as (self-employed) business activity. As long as the purpose of the participation is not to increase income or reduce expenses within the scope of the original gainful activity (in this case the activity as a lawyer), there is no room to assume that the participation is a business asset or to assume self-employment. Nevertheless, the qualification as business assets is not excluded, as the participation could also form part of commercial securities trading.

COMMERCIAL SECURITIES TRADING

Under certain circumstances, the (profitable) sale of shares can be regarded as commercial se-curities trading and thus as self-employment. In practice, the following criteria are used for this purpose [4]:

  • Transaction volume (frequency of transactions and short holding period)
  • Use of substantial external funds to finance the transactions
  • Use of derivatives
  • Systematic or planned way of proceeding
  • Close connection of the transactions with the professional activity of the taxable person and the use of special expertise

In this context, reference should be made to a ruling by the Federal Supreme Court [5], in which it had to deal with the sale of a shareholding that was classified as commercial securities trading by the lower courts. Specifically, a person who was initially still working as an independent man-agement consultant acquired a stake in a holding company that held two subsidiaries operating in the packaging industry. These companies were in financial difficulties, which made restructuring measures necessary. Together with another business partner, the person concerned succeeded in restructuring the companies and then selling them at a profit. The responsible tax office and the Federal Tax Administration were of the opinion that this approach went beyond the scope of private asset management, meaning that the realized increase in value would constitute (subse-quent) remuneration for the intensive restructuring efforts and thus income from self-employment from an economic point of view. In this regard, the Federal Supreme Court stated that, from a tax perspective, owners of participations are not prohibited from attempting to in-crease the value of the participation by participating in the company. [6] In this specific case, there was therefore no basis for a subsequent reclassification of the capital gain as remuneration for work performed, meaning that the gain could be recognized as a tax-free capital gain.

TAKING ADVANTAGE OF A ONE TIME OPPORTUNITY

Although the term "trader" is often associated with repeated purchases and sales, the single sale of an asset can also be regarded as self-employment under certain circumstances. From a tax perspective, it is questionable whether the single sale of an asset can lead to the assumption of self-employment as a trader.

According to the case law of the Federal Supreme Court, the mere one-off sale of an asset does not in principle protect against the assumption of self-employment. For example, the sale of a single property or the (partial) sale of a shareholding can lead to the assumption of (part time) self-employed. However, this requires that the asset in question was acquired as part of a planned, acquisition-oriented activity and managed with a view to a future profitable sale. A tax-free capital gain from the sale of an individual asset is therefore only possible if the sale can still be attributed to private asset management. This is invariably the case when a one-time oppor-tunity is taken - whereby the burden of proof lies with the taxpayer. As long as the threshold for self-employment is not exceeded, a certain asset management activity in relation to the asset to be sold should not be detrimental. However, the circumstances of the specific individual case must always be considered.

According to federal court rulings, if an occupation is primarily held as a form of employment, part-time self-employment may be considered in exceptional cases and under specific circum-stances. Indications in this regard include any external financing, risks taken or a particularly sys-tematic or planned approach. The proximity to the profession and the specialist knowledge used are also indications to be considered. The Federal Supreme Court has determined that the amount of profit made is of secondary importance.[7]

A current example is provided by the Federal Supreme Court [8]: In this instance, the revenue de-rived from the one-time sale of a share was classified as income from self-employment. The decisive factor was that the taxpayer was systematically and entrepreneurially involved in the project over a longer period of time, invested considerable financial resources, took entrepre-neurial risks and cooperated with an experienced business partner. Despite the lack of repetition of this activity, these circumstances were sufficient to assume a taxable gainful activity.

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

The distinction between tax-free capital gains and taxable income is complex in many cases and depends on various indicators. In order to realize a tax-free capital gain, it is important to careful-ly examine the relevant criteria and, if necessary, take measures in good time to avoid tax disad-vantages. Early and forward-looking planning is essential in view of the tax consequences of refusing the benefit of tax-free capital gains. This applies all the more as social security contribu-tions are due on the capital gain in addition to income tax.

[1]           Cf. judgment FSC 9C_454/2023 of December 11, 2024.
[2]           Cf. judgment FSC 2A.547/2004 of April 22, 2005.
[3]           Cf. judgment FSC 9C_454/2023 of December 11, 2024.
[4]           Cf. circular letter of the FTA no. 36, section 4.3.2.
[5]           Cf. judgment FSC 2C_115/2012 and 2C_116/2012 of September 25, 2012.
[6]           Cf. judgment FSC 2C_115/2012 and 2C_116/2012 of September 25, 2012 E. 2.5.3.
[7]           See in particular.judgment FSC 9C_403/2023 of June 25, 2024 E. 5.5.
[8]           See in particular. judgment FSC 9C_403/2023 of June 25, 2024.

On 16 December 2025, the Zurich Tax Office published two new practice notices on indirect partial liquidation. They concern the relevant balance sheet date and the inclusion of group companies in determining the commercially distributable reserves. In the view expressed here, both notices are declaratory in nature — they clarify existing law rather than introduce any genuine change in practice. They are nonetheless significant for day-to-day transactions.

I. BASIC ELEMENTS OF INDIRECT PARTIAL LIQUIDATION

So-called indirect partial liquidation covers situations in which a shareholder disposes of a participation held as private assets to a corporation or cooperative, or to a natural person holding the participation as business assets, and the target company subsequently distributes substance that would economically have benefited the seller. The legislature seeks to prevent commercially distributable reserves — which would be taxable as a dividend triggering income tax or profit tax for the seller — from being realized tax-free via the interposition of a corporate acquisition.

The provision requires the following elements to be met cumulatively:

(1) Disposal of a participation of at least 20% in a corporation or cooperative,

(2) to a corporation or cooperative (acquiring company),

(3) distribution of commercially distributable, non-operationally necessary substance of the target company within a lock-up period of five years following the sale,

(4) to the extent this distribution exceeds the profits ordinarily generated since the acquisition, and

(5) cooperation by the seller in the distribution.

The legal consequence is that the realized gain is in general re-assessed as income from movable assets in the seller’s hands — the tax-free capital gain is thereby reclassified, to that extent, as taxable income from movable assets.

Two figures are central to calculating the exposure from an indirect partial liquidation: on the one hand, the distributable reserves of the target company at the time of the sale, and on the other, the non-operationally necessary substance. The lower of the two amounts is determinative in each case. It is these calculation parameters — in particular the relevant point in time and the circle of companies to be included — that the Zurich Tax Office clarifies with its new practice notices of 16 December 2025.

II. RELEVANT BALANCE SHEET DATE (ZSTB NO. 20A.2)[1]

In principle, the last annual financial statements (or the last interim accounts) of the target company approved by the general meeting (hereinafter: “AGM”) prior to the sale are to be used to determine the distributable reserves. With its practice notice on determining the point in time of the distributable reserves, the Zurich Tax Office confirms the administrative practice set out in Circular No. 14 of the SFTA as well as the Federal Supreme Court ruling 2C_135/2021 of 2 March 2022.[2]

The supplementary clarification regarding the six-month period is of practical importance: if the sale takes place more than six months after the balance sheet date, the profit of the preceding financial year is deemed to constitute distributable substance — regardless of whether the AGM has already taken place at the time of the sale or not.[3]  This must be seen against the civil law background that the AGM is to be held within six months of the balance sheet date. If, contrary to that requirement, no AGM takes place within this period, reference is still to be made to the last balance sheet date even without the annual accounts having been approved by the AGM.

The practice notice illustrates this with three scenarios:

  • Sale within 6 months in year N, before the AGM → determinative: balance sheet of the prior year (Year N-2)
  • Sale within 6 months in year N, after the AGM → determinative: balance sheet of the current year (Year N-1)
  • Sale after expiry of 6 months in year N → determinative: balance sheet Year N-1, timing of AGM irrelevant

The principle of relying on the last approved annual accounts is not absolute. If a material change in the financial position of the target company occurs between the balance sheet date and the sale — for example through extraordinary distributions, the disposal of significant assets, or substantial losses — it may be justified to use a more current basis or to depart from the last annual accounts approved by the AGM.[4]  This applies in particular if, after the AGM but prior to the sale, the commercially distributable reserves are actually distributed to the sellers.

Assessment: This practice notice introduces nothing substantively new. It does, however, create clarity for situations in which closing and AGM occur in close temporal proximity — a frequent occurrence in practice. For transacting parties who can actively control their closing date, the balance sheet date remains a relevant planning parameter, though artificial postponement of the AGM to reduce distributable substance could be treated as tax avoidance.

III. DETERMINING THE COMMERCIALLY DISTRIBUTABLE RESERVES (ZSTB NO. 20A.3)[5]

The second practice notice appears, at first glance, more substantively significant. The Zurich Tax Office states that in determining the distributable reserves, not only the target company itself but also its subsidiaries and sub-subsidiaries under unified management are to be included.[6] The analysis is conducted for each entity individually (single-entity financial statements; no consolidation). Losses of individual group companies cannot therefore be offset against distributable reserves of other companies.

In concrete terms, this means: the determinative amount is the lower of non-operationally necessary substance and commercially distributable reserves — per entity, pro rata according to the ownership percentage. Minority interests (without a majority of voting rights) fall outside the calculation. The potential tax base arising from an indirect partial liquidation can therefore not be artificially reduced by keeping distributable reserves at the target company level low while accumulating reserves in subsidiaries instead.

Assessment: While neither Circular No. 14 nor prior cantonal practice addressed the group-wide entity-by-entity analysis with comparable explicitness, this practice notice, in the view expressed here, merely concretizes a principle of group-wide analysis that was already applicable before its publication and does not bring about any material change in practice. Regardless, it provides welcome clarity on this point.

IV. IMPACT ON EXISTING RULINGS AND ALREADY-COMPLETED TRANSACTIONS

In the view expressed here, the new practice notices are declaratory in character: they clarify and illustrate principles that already followed from existing law and the established literature. This has consequences for the assessment of existing rulings and already-completed transactions.

For existing rulings, this means: where the calculation of the commercially distributable reserves was the subject of the ruling and was specifically determined — including at group level — the protection of legitimate expectations is evident. The same must apply where the amount of the commercially distributable reserves was fixed — for whatever reason — without regard to direct or indirect subsidiaries. Provided the other requirements for protection of legitimate expectations are met — in particular full and accurate disclosure of the facts and no material change in the legal or factual position — such a ruling that is substantively incorrect remains binding on the authority.

For already-completed transactions without a ruling, the same logic applies: since the group-wide entity-by-entity analysis, in the view expressed here, already applied prior to publication of the practice notice, open assessments may in principle be determined according to these principles. Taxpayers who have to date not included subsidiaries in the IPL calculation bear the risk of a revised assessment, provided the tax assessment has not yet become final.

V. PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS FOR TRANSACTIONS

For ongoing and planned transactions, the IPL analysis must be conducted from the outset at the level of all subsidiaries and sub-subsidiaries under unified management — regardless of where distributable reserves are accumulated within the group. Existing calculations limited to the target company alone should be reviewed.

The timing of the sale relative to the balance sheet date and the AGM remains a relevant planning parameter. In particular for transactions in the second half of the year, the implications of the six-month period should be analyzed at an early stage. An artificial delay of the AGM to reduce distributable substance carries the risk of being treated as tax avoidance. Against this background, it is advisable to schedule the AGM consistently in the second quarter, independently of any potential sale. An ad hoc postponement of the AGM is difficult to defend; a temporally consistent practice offers adequate protection against the allegation of tax avoidance by comparison.

[1]    https://www.zh.ch/de/steuern-finanzen/steuern/treuhaender/steuerbuch/steuerbuch-definition/zstb-nr-20a-2.html
[2]    See for the same practice in the Canton of Aargau: ATTENHOFER/SCHWARB/BAUMER, in: Klöti-Weber/Schudel/Schwarb (eds.), Kommentar zum Aargauer Steuergesetz, 5th ed., Bern 2023, § 29a N 63a
[3]    See also ATTENHOFER/SCHWARB/BAUMER, op. cit., § 29a N 63a in fine in fine
[4]    See ATTENHOFER/SCHWARB/BAUMER, op. cit., § 29a N 63
[5]    https://www.zh.ch/de/steuern-finanzen/steuern/treuhaender/steuerbuch/steuerbuch-definition/zstb-nr-20a-3.html
[6]    See also ATTENHOFER/SCHWARB/BAUMER, op. cit., § 29a N 60

The Swiss Federal Council intends to reduce the administrative burden on businesses. On 19 June 2026, it launched two consultation procedures[1] proposing targeted simplifications in the areas of value added tax (VAT), Swiss withholding tax and stamp duties. The objective is to reduce recurring compliance obligations vis-à-vis the Swiss Federal Tax Administration (SFTA) without altering taxpayers' substantive tax obligations.

I. FOUR KEY MEASURES

The proposal focuses on four measures relating to VAT, Swiss withholding tax and issuance stamp duty

1. VAT: Annual VAT Returns Without a Turnover Threshold

Since the beginning of 2025, businesses with annual turnover of up to CHF 5,005,000 have been permitted to file VAT returns annually rather than quarterly. The draft legislation proposes to abolish this turnover threshold entirely. Consequently, all VAT-registered businesses, irrespective of their annual turnover, would be eligible to opt for annual VAT reporting. The application requirement, instalment payments and filing deadlines would remain unchanged.

2. Swiss Withholding Tax: Extension of the Notification Procedure Within Corporate Groups

The notification procedure would no longer be limited to direct parent-subsidiary relationships. Instead, it would be extended to a broader range of intra-group transactions, including companies that are fully or proportionately consolidated under recognized accounting standards. In certain cases, the procedure could also apply where the shareholding is below 10%.

3. Fewer Mandatory Filings

The current obligation to submit annual financial statements to the SFTA without request once total assets exceed CHF 5 million would be relaxed. For Swiss withholding tax purposes, financial statements would only need to be submitted where taxable distributions (such as dividends or taxable deemed profit distributions (constructive dividends under Swiss tax law)) have actually occurred. For issuance stamp duty purposes, financial statements would generally only need to be submitted upon request by the SFTA, although the authority would retain the right to request them in individual cases.

4. Issuance Stamp Duty: Easier Relief for Corporate Restructurings

The current exemption from issuance stamp duty for restructuring contributions is limited to CHF 10 million, subject to the possibility of applying for additional relief. The proposal would abolish this limitation. Both open restructuring measures and hidden restructuring measures would be fully exempt from issuance stamp duty, irrespective of the amount contributed, provided that existing losses are eliminated. The current hardship relief procedure would therefore become obsolete.

II. CURRENT STATUS AND TIMELINE

An indication of the intended direction can already be seen in the SFTA Practice Notice of 22 June 2026[2], by which the SFTA abolished the obligation for securities dealers to submit nil returns for securities transfer stamp duty purposes. The legislative proposals themselves remain at the consultation stage. Their entry into force is therefore uncertain, and the proposed amendments remain subject to the optional referendum process. Certain amendments at ordinance level could enter into force earlier. However, the extension of the notification procedure is expressly intended to become effective only once the necessary IT adaptations within the SFTA have been completed.

III. ASSESSMENT: LESS FORMALISM – NOT LESS RESPONSIBILITY

The overall direction of the proposals deserves support. Recurring and largely formalistic filing obligations consume resources for both businesses and the tax authorities without generally generating any meaningful additional information. The extension of the notification procedure is likely to provide significant liquidity benefits, while abolishing the restructuring threshold removes an unnecessary procedural obstacle for companies already facing financial distress.

A. Expansion of the Notification Procedure Within Corporate Groups

Under the current wording of the law, the notification procedure is available in particular for dividend distributions and constructive dividends within domestic and cross-border group structures. Rather than requiring the deduction of the 35% Swiss withholding tax followed by a subsequent refund, the notification procedure allows the tax obligation to be fulfilled simply by filing a notification. Despite the wording of the statute, however, the notification procedure is currently available only in direct parent-subsidiary relationships because the implementing ordinance requires a minimum shareholding of 10%. Where this threshold is not met, withholding tax on constructive dividends may currently be settled through the notification procedure only if the taxable benefit is discovered during an official tax audit It should be noted that the notification procedure is available only where it is established that the recipient of the payment is substantively entitled to a refund of the notified withholding tax. If there is any doubt – for example regarding beneficial ownership or old reserves – the withholding tax must still be levied, passed on to the recipient and default interest will accrue. Acceptance of the notification by the Swiss Federal Tax Administration does not prevent a subsequent reassessment, nor does it preclude criminal tax proceedings. Conversely, taxpayers who voluntarily pay the withholding tax lose the possibility of using the notification procedure permanently. Failure to submit a notification, or submitting an incorrect notification, may furthermore result in tax evasion proceedings carrying a fine of up to CHF 30,000 or, if higher, up to three times the amount of tax evaded. It should further be noted that an ordinary notification – i.e. one submitted outside the context of an official audit – must generally be filed within 30 days after the taxable benefit becomes due. For many years, this deadline carried significant consequences, as until February 2017 it constituted a forfeiture period. Taxpayers who filed their notification late permanently lost access to the notification procedure and became liable for default interest, then amounting to 5% of the full withholding tax, even where their entitlement to a refund was undisputed. Since February 2017, however, taxpayers satisfying the substantive requirements remain entitled to the notification procedure even if the notification is filed late, without incurring default interest. Instead of forfeiture, late filing is now punishable by an administrative fine of up to CHF 5,000.

B. The Other Side of the Coin

While the reduction of administrative burdens is clearly welcome, it is also worth considering the other side of the coin. The taxes concerned – VAT, Swiss withholding tax and stamp duties – are all based on the principle of self-assessment. Determining the relevant facts, correctly classifying transactions and remitting the tax due remain primarily the responsibility of the taxpayer rather than the tax authorities. The consultation proposal does not alter this fundamental principle. It merely reduces the frequency and density of the administrative filing obligations that have traditionally accompanied it. For taxpayers, this effectively means a shift from routine filing obligations to maintaining documentation that can be produced promptly upon request by the Swiss Federal Tax Administration. Financial statements must therefore remain readily available, even for previous tax periods, and classification errors are more likely to come to light only during targeted audits, potentially covering several years, rather than through the routine review processes that have existed until now. From a practical perspective, this means that administrative simplification should not be mistaken for a relaxation of the taxpayer's duty of care. Where existing administrative control points are removed, businesses should compensate through appropriate internal procedures, such as well-documented analyses of intra-group transactions or robust internal processes for determining whether a taxable event has occurred. Practical experience shows that the breach of what are often perceived as "merely" administrative obligations regularly results in costly consequences, including default interest, administrative penalties and, in more serious cases, criminal tax proceedings – all of which could often have been avoided with comparatively little additional effort. Businesses wishing to benefit from the newly gained flexibility would therefore be well advised to accompany it with a corresponding increase in internal vigilance. Simplifying procedural requirements does not diminish responsibility for ensuring substantive tax compliance. This observation applies equally to issuance stamp duty. The explanatory report expressly reserves cases involving abuse of law, for example excessive write-downs intended to create tax losses or incorporations with manifestly insufficient share capital followed by restructuring contributions. The more generous exemption

[1] Cf. Federal Council press release dated 19 June 2026 (see HERE).
[2] Cf. SFTA announcement of 22 June 2026 (see LINK).

Tax domicile conflicts are decided at the level of the facts, but the procedural level must not be neglected. Anyone who disregards the rules of evidence, the duties to cooperate or the applicable deadlines risks definitive double taxation or substantial cost consequences despite a sound position on the merits. This article summarises the procedural rules as refined and, in part, tightened by the Federal Supreme Court in 2025 and 2026. The substantive questions are addressed in separate articles on the tax residence of individuals, on the tax residence of companies and on the position in an international context.

I. TRIGGER AND COURSE OF TAX DOMICILE PROCEEDINGS

Tax domicile proceedings are frequently triggered by the filing of a tax return or by notification of a departure that the previously competent authority is unwilling to accept. For companies, the focus is on transfers of the registered office, on the residence and functions of the members of the governing bodies, or on irregularities in the tax file (for example the absence of rental and personnel expenses at the registered office); investigations may also be prompted by information from third parties or by notifications from other tax authorities. Information from criminal proceedings which the tax authorities have transmitted to foreign prosecution authorities by way of mutual legal assistance may likewise form the basis for tax domicile proceedings.

Where the tax administration harbours a suspicion, a formal request for documents (Aktenauflage) generally follows. In the case of individuals, it may call for floor plans, details of the furnishings, electricity and water consumption figures, or complete records of cash withdrawals and card payments. In the case of companies, it may call for evidence of premises, decision-making processes and presence at the registered office.

The scope of such requests can be considerable and at times appears disproportionate, coming close to a “fishing expedition”. In some cases the authorities also carry out their own enquiries and obtain relevant information – consumption data, for instance – themselves, without disclosing this from the outset.

Anyone contesting a canton’s tax sovereignty is, in principle, entitled to formal tax sovereignty proceedings (also referred to as tax domicile proceedings). The pending assessment or supplementary tax proceedings must be stayed, and the authority must first determine, in a binding tax domicile decision, whether it may tax the person concerned at all. The ordinary legal remedies are available against that decision.

The Federal Supreme Court has abandoned its previous practice as regards the effect of that decision.[1] In the Court’s view, the tax domicile decision is a preliminary or interlocutory decision and does not acquire substantive res judicata effect. The question of tax liability may be raised again when the subsequent assessment or supplementary tax order is challenged. This does not, however, apply without limitation: anyone who allows a tax domicile decision to become final without challenging it must cooperate in the ensuing assessment proceedings and cannot contest tax liability again absent a material change in circumstances. [2]

II. JURISDICTION – TWO SETS OF PROCEEDINGS, TWO AVENUES OF APPEAL

A. Diverging jurisdictions

It is frequently overlooked that cantonal tax domicile proceedings cover only the cantonal and communal taxes. For direct federal tax, the principle of the unity of the place of assessment applies: even where connecting factors exist in several cantons, only one single canton may assess the same taxable person for the same tax period.

Where the place of assessment is uncertain or disputed, it is determined by the Federal Tax Administration (FTA) as soon as more than one canton comes into consideration. Such a determination may be requested by the assessment authority, by the cantonal administration for direct federal tax and by the taxable person. The FTA’s order may be appealed to the Federal Administrative Court.

B. Determination of the place of assessment by the FTA

The cantonal tax and tax appeal authorities have no jurisdiction in this respect. Where a cantonal authority nevertheless determines its own jurisdiction to assess direct federal tax although it is obvious that another canton comes into consideration as the place of assessment, its decision and the appeal decisions confirming it are null and void. It makes no difference whether the canton rules on the place of assessment as the principal issue – by way of a tax sovereignty order – or merely as a preliminary issue within the assessment.[3] The nullity is, however, confined to direct federal tax; the tax domicile decision concerning the cantonal and communal taxes remains unaffected.

In this respect, the FTA does not act in a supervisory capacity but within the assessment procedure. It decides as a neutral body, in the nature of an “arbitrator”, and must rule on the place of assessment independently and on the basis of its own assessment of the merits.[4] This also entails a procedural limitation: where the FTA has issued an order in proceedings under Art. 108 DBG, it cannot challenge an unwelcome decision of the Federal Administrative Court by way of an authority appeal under Art. 89 para. 2 lit. a of the Federal Supreme Court Act (BGG), since it may not supervise itself.[5] The decision of the Federal Administrative Court is therefore final in effect, unless it is appealed by the taxable person or by a canton concerned.

C. Parallel proceedings

In practice, two sets of proceedings therefore run alongside one another: the cantonal tax sovereignty proceedings, through the cantonal instances to the Federal Supreme Court, and the determination proceedings under Art. 108 of the Federal Act on Direct Federal Taxation (DBG), through the Federal Administrative Court. How closely the two strands can be intertwined is illustrated by a recent case in which the taxable person filed an objection against the cantonal assessment and, on the same day, requested the FTA to determine the place of assessment, while cantonal tax domicile proceedings were also pending.[6] No coordination takes place: the FTA may not stay its proceedings until the cantonal proceedings concerning the cantonal and communal taxes have become final.[7]

Anyone pursuing the cantonal route alone risks not only that the position on direct federal tax remains unresolved, but also that the appeal is declared inadmissible for want of a challengeable decision.[8]

III. BURDEN OF PROOF, STANDARD OF PROOF AND DUTY TO COOPERATE

A. Principle

As a matter of principle, facts that establish or increase a tax liability must be proved by the tax administration, while facts that eliminate or reduce it must be proved by the taxable person. Where a canton claims tax sovereignty for the first time or anew, the burden of proof therefore lies with the tax administration.

B. Consequences for legal entities

For legal entities, tax sovereignty attaches to the registered office or to the place of effective management. Where a canton claims tax sovereignty on the ground that the effective management is located on its territory, it bears the burden of proving this, although the reduced standard of the balance of probabilities suffices for that proof.[9] If it establishes that the registered office in the other canton is a mere letterbox domicile, this constitutes a weighty indicium that the effective management is located on its territory. In that case, the legal entity must adduce counter-evidence (de facto reversal of the burden of proof) and demonstrate that it carries on substantial activities at the registered office or that the effective management takes place there.

C. Consequences for individuals

For individuals, tax sovereignty attaches to the centre of vital interests. Where a canton claims tax sovereignty for the first time or anew after a number of years, it bears the burden of proving the facts establishing the tax liability, and here too the reduced standard of the balance of probabilities suffices.[10] What is decisive is not a presumption in favour of the previous place of residence but an overall assessment of all indicia: the sole question is where the centre of vital interests was actually located. A transfer of residence does not require, in particular, that all ties to the previous place be severed. It is to be assumed as soon as the ties to the new place prevail on balance.[11]

D. Obligation to cooperate

Since the authorities are frequently unable to establish the relevant facts themselves, they depend on the cooperation of those concerned. Under the case law of the Federal Supreme Court, a certain duty to cooperate exists even before tax sovereignty has been established with final effect. Where the authority identifies sufficient indicia, it is for the person concerned to rebut them. To that extent, the burden of proof gives rise to a de facto duty to cooperate.

In addition, insufficient cooperation in tax domicile proceedings that have been legitimately initiated may, according to settled case law, be taken into account as an indicium to the detriment of the person concerned.[12] Silence can therefore cost more than an uncomfortable disclosure.

Where the circumstances are personal in nature, the duty to cooperate extends even into the private affairs of the shareholder. In the case of one-person companies, that person forms the “epicentre” of the enquiries. Private credit card and bank account statements may therefore, in principle, also be requested.

Failure to comply with the duty to cooperate may be sanctioned by a fine. The ordinary range extends to CHF 1,000, and in serious cases or in the event of a repeat offence to CHF 10,000. In our view, however, there is no breach of procedural duty where the person concerned submits other documents that are objectively suitable for clarifying the tax domicile and the documents called for are no longer available or could be obtained only by disproportionate means.

IV. ELIMINATION OF INTERCANTONAL DOUBLE TAXATION

Where the tax domicile is determined contrary to the taxpayer’s own view and the taxes have already been assessed with final effect in the other canton, actual double taxation arises. Such double taxation is prohibited under constitutional law (Art. 127 para. 3 Cst.) and must be eliminated. As a rule, the route to elimination leads via the Federal Supreme Court, which has the power to set aside assessment orders of the other canton even where these have already become final.

A. The bidirectional prayer for relief: an indispensable requirement

The Federal Supreme Court has recently tightened the formal requirements for lodging an appeal. In a recent judgment it held that the prayers for relief must be framed in “bidirectional” terms.[13]

In addition to the principal prayer directed against the one canton, a complementary alternative prayer directed against the other canton (which has already issued a final assessment) must be filed within the appeal period, together with an application for the refund of, and where applicable interest on, the taxes paid there.

The Federal Supreme Court has expressly abandoned its former practice, under which “no high requirements” were to be placed on the joint challenge to the other canton and an implicit alternative prayer sufficed. A presumption of an implicit joint challenge no longer applies as a matter of course. An alternative prayer submitted after expiry of the appeal period will be disregarded. Anyone taking only one canton to court therefore risks being left to bear the taxes paid in the other canton.

B. Forfeiture and cost consequences

Under the more recent case law, the right to have double taxation eliminated is forfeited only in the event of a qualified abuse of rights, such as the construction of an elaborate web of lies or the misrepresentation of facts. The threshold is high – but conduct contrary to good faith, or even merely unclear conduct, may be taken into account by the Federal Supreme Court when allocating costs:

In a judgment of 23 June 2026,[14] the successful company was ordered to bear all court costs notwithstanding that the assessments of the canton of its registered office were set aside; in addition, it had to pay the canton of Zug, against which it had prevailed, a party costs award of CHF 2,600. The same applies to a judgment of 22 July 2026:[15] the Federal Supreme Court rejected the second canton’s plea of forfeiture and set aside that canton’s final assessment – yet the successful taxpayer bore the court costs (CHF 3,000) and was awarded no party costs.

Success on the merits therefore offers no protection against the cost consequences where a party’s own conduct in the proceedings gives cause for criticism.

V. REVISION AND RECONSIDERATION IN THE CANTON OF FIRST ASSESSMENT

Some cantons have included the elimination of intercantonal double taxation in their tax legislation as a statutory ground for revision. It was long disputed whether double taxation could, beyond this, be eliminated on the basis of the Federal Constitution by way of an “extra-statutory” revision.[16] The Federal Supreme Court provided clarity on this point in a judgment of 1 May 2025.[17] No entitlement to an extra-statutory ground for revision can be derived from the Federal Constitution. Apart from the statutory grounds for reopening a final assessment (revision, correction and supplementary taxation), there are no others.

The cantons are nevertheless free to reconsider final assessments in cases of intercantonal double taxation for as long as the route to the Federal Supreme Court remains open. Unlike revision, however, there is no entitlement to have the request taken up by the authority at all.

The cantons may, moreover, subject reconsideration to a time limit; a period of 90 days from notification of the other canton’s tax domicile decision is compatible with federal law. Anyone intending to rely on reconsideration must therefore keep this deadline in view from the outset.

VI. THE CRIMINAL LAW DIMENSION

If the tax domicile is not situated at the place previously declared and no taxes have been paid at the relevant place to date, the objective elements of the offence of tax evasion may be made out. The fact that the taxes were properly declared and paid elsewhere makes no difference. Only culpable conduct is punishable, however; in tax domicile cases there will as a rule – if at all – only be attempted tax evasion, the punishability of which requires intent. In practice, that proof is likely to succeed only in exceptional individual cases.

Nevertheless, some tax authorities combine tax domicile proceedings (in particular in the context of supplementary tax proceedings) with the opening of penalty proceedings; and where the taxable person has behaved improperly, the Federal Supreme Court expressly refers the cantons to the instruments of criminal tax law. There is thus a risk that, even where (legal) double taxation has been successfully eliminated, an economic double burden will remain if a fine for tax evasion is imposed. Finally, it should be noted that a fine exceeding CHF 5,000 in respect of direct federal tax entails the risk of an entry in the criminal record.

VII. CONCLUSION AND PRACTICAL CHECKLIST

The case law of 2025 and 2026 has significantly sharpened the procedural requirements in tax domicile cases. The following basic rules can be derived for practice:

  • Respond to a tax authority’s first enquiry cooperatively and with supporting evidence, because insufficient cooperation may be treated as an indicium.
  • Where the request for documents is very extensive and the documents called for are not available in full, respond with suitable alternative evidence rather than leaving the request unanswered.
  • Keep the deadlines consistently in view – both for challenging the tax domicile decision and for a request for reconsideration in the other canton, where a period of only 90 days from notification of the tax domicile decision may already be running.
  • In proceedings before the Federal Supreme Court, always frame the prayers for relief bidirectionally, including the refund of, and interest on, the taxes paid in the other canton.

In the event of a dispute at the latest, it is advisable to involve a specialist – because in tax domicile proceedings the conduct of the case increasingly determines the outcome. Here too, it is better to be safe than sorry.

Last updated: 25 September 2026

 

[1] See BGE 151 II 657.
[2] See Federal Supreme Court judgment 9C_602/2024 of 25 March 2025.
[3] See BGE 150 II 244.
[4] See Federal Supreme Court judgment 9C_173/2026 of 28 August 2026, consid. 1.4.1 f. (intended for publication).
[5] See Federal Supreme Court judgment 9C_173/2026 of 28 August 2026, consid. 1.4.7 f. (intended for publication).
[6] See Federal Administrative Court judgment A-6994/2025 of 21 July 2026.
[7] See Federal Administrative Court judgment A-6987/2025 of 3 February 2026.
[8] See Federal Supreme Court judgments 9C_706/2024 and 9C_154/2025 both of 27 August 2025.
[9] See BGE 150 II 321.
[10] See Federal Supreme Court judgment BGer 9C_157/2025 from 19. March 2026.
[11] See Federal Supreme Court judgment BGer 9C_73/2025 vom 2. April 2026.
[12] See most recently Federal Supreme Court judgments BGer 9C_702/2024 of 13 January 2026; 9C_558/2024 vom 29. April 2025 and 9C_570/2024 both of 29 April 2025.
[13] See Federal Supreme Court judgment BGer 9C_652/2025 of 9. June 2026.
[14] See Federal Supreme Court judgment 9C_452/2025 of 23. June 2026.
[15] See Federal Supreme Court judgment 9C_391/2025 of 22. July 2026.
[16] Specifically: Appenzell Ausserrhoden, Lucerne, St. Gallen, Solothurn and Ticino..
[17] See BGE 151 II 673.

In its judgment 9C_697/2024 of 2 June 2026, the Federal Supreme Court provided important legal certainty on the treatment of foreign single-investor funds for transfer stamp tax purposes. Switzerland's highest court made clear that a foreign single-investor fund may also qualify as an investor exempt from transfer stamp tax. The decisive factor is that the fund is recognised as a collective investment scheme in its home jurisdiction. The stricter Swiss requirements for single-investor funds do not have to be met additionally.

The judgment is relevant to Swiss securities dealers that trade with or invest in foreign funds. To ensure that the exemption does not fail for lack of documentation, the fund's exempt status must be recorded in the securities turnover register and supported by evidence. Anyone who has paid transfer stamp tax in comparable cases or is currently subject to an SFTA audit should consider seeking a refund.

BACKGROUND

A Swiss corporation that was liable for transfer stamp tax as a securities dealer under Art. 13 para. 3 let. d of the Swiss Stamp Duty Act (SDA) invested as the sole investor in an alternative investment fund established under Liechtenstein law in the form of a collective trusteeship (“Kollektivtreuhänderschaft”). The fund was managed by a manager domiciled in Liechtenstein, while portfolio management was delegated to a Swiss company.

Under the customs union treaty, Liechtenstein is treated as domestic territory for transfer stamp tax purposes. For financial market law purposes,[1] however, the fund, which had its registered office and head office in Liechtenstein, remained a foreign vehicle. The exemption could therefore apply only if it qualified as a foreign collective investment scheme under Art. 119 of the Collective Investment Schemes Act (CISA).

Following an audit, the SFTA attributed the fund's securities transactions for the 2016 to 2020 tax periods directly to the investor. Its reasoning was that the fund was not an exempt investor because, as a single-investor fund, it lacked the requisite collective character. The company paid transfer stamp tax of CHF 369'681.18 plus default interest subject to a reservation of rights and challenged the assessment. Both its objection and its appeal to the Federal Administrative Court were unsuccessful.

THE POINT IN DISPUTE: THE COLLECTIVE CHARACTER OF A SINGLE-INVESTOR FUND

According to the SFTA's position, which the Federal Administrative Court upheld, foreign vehicles must have an equivalent under Swiss law. The definition of a foreign collective investment scheme under Art. 119 CISA had to be based on Art. 7 CISA. Swiss law permits only a narrow group of qualified investors to invest in domestic single-investor funds: supervised insurance institutions, public-law entities with professional treasury operations and occupational pension institutions with professional treasury operations.[2] The investor did not belong to any of these categories. It would not have been permitted to invest in a Swiss single-investor fund. The Liechtenstein fund could therefore not qualify as an exempt investor either.

THE FEDERAL SUPREME COURT'S INTERPRETATION: ART. 119 CISA STANDS ON ITS OWN

The Federal Supreme Court rejected this approach. The wording of Art. 17a para. 1 let. c SDA refers to Art. 119 CISA without any qualification. Only the parallel provision for domestic collective investment schemes refers to Art. 7 CISA and its restrictive para. 3 governing single-investor funds. Art. 119 CISA itself contains no comparable restriction. The structure of the CISA also distinguishes between the two concepts: Art. 7 CISA appears in the general provisions governing domestic schemes, whereas Art. 119 CISA appears in a separate title governing foreign schemes.

The legislative materials proved decisive. The legislature was aware of the diversity of foreign investment vehicles and, specifically with single-investor funds from Liechtenstein and Luxembourg in mind, deliberately adopted a broader concept of foreign collective investment schemes. If a foreign legal system provides more permissive rules for single-investor funds than Swiss law, the vehicle nevertheless qualifies as a foreign collective investment scheme under Art. 119 CISA.

The Court did, however, impose one limit: it did not accept the appellant's argument that FINMA's practice alone should be decisive. Classification is determined by Art. 119 CISA itself, not by an administrative recognition practice.

THE SFTA HELD TO ITS OWN CIRCULAR

Notably, the Federal Supreme Court also relied on the SFTA's own circular to support its interpretation. Section 3.1.1.1 of Circular No. 24 states that single-investor funds are recognised for Swiss tax purposes if they are accepted as such by the relevant foreign supervisory authority for collective investment schemes. Liechtenstein is included in the list of foreign supervisory authorities recognised by the SFTA in Annex V to the circular.[3] In this case, the SFTA had therefore adopted a position that contradicted its own published practice. The fund qualified as a foreign collective investment scheme and thus as an exempt investor.

The Federal Supreme Court allowed the appeal in full. The SFTA must refund transfer stamp tax of CHF 369'681.18 plus default interest.[4]

PRACTICAL SIGNIFICANCE

The judgment removes considerable legal uncertainty in the area of transfer stamp tax.

The previous two-stage test is no longer required. To qualify for the transfer stamp tax exemption, foreign funds do not have to satisfy the Swiss requirements under Art. 7 CISA and Art. 5 CISO in addition to the regulatory requirements of their home jurisdiction. Foreign single-investor funds qualify as exempt investors if the competent foreign supervisory authority accepts them as collective investment schemes. This applies even if the underlying sole investor would not be permitted to invest in a single-investor fund in Switzerland. Securities dealers may rely on section 3.1.1.1 of Circular No. 24 and the country list in Annex V. This makes the counterparty review significantly more practicable for securities dealers.

Documentation nevertheless remains critical. Transfer stamp tax operates on a self-assessment basis. The counterparty's exempt status must be recorded in the securities turnover register and supported by evidence. Otherwise, at the next audit the exemption may fail for lack of proof rather than as a matter of law.[5] For each foreign fund, securities dealers should document that the vehicle meets Art. 119 CISA and that the relevant foreign supervisory authority accepts it as a collective investment scheme.

Anyone who has paid transfer stamp tax in comparable circumstances, whether subject to a reservation of rights or following an SFTA audit, should consider seeking a refund. Depending on the calendar year, the refund interest rate ranges from 4% to 4.75%, making a refund financially attractive as well. The judgment provides a basis for argument in ongoing audits and pending proceedings.

CONCLUSION

In judgment 9C_697/2024, the Federal Supreme Court clarified that the transfer stamp tax exemption for foreign collective investment schemes must be assessed independently under Art. 119 CISA. The SFTA’s attempt to apply the restrictions governing domestic funds to foreign vehicles fails in light of the wording, structure and legislative materials – as well as the SFTA's own circular. The judgment provides welcome legal certainty for the fund industry and Swiss securities dealers. A securities dealer entering into transactions with foreign single-investor funds may rely on recognition by the foreign supervisory authority, but must document the fund's status carefully. Anyone who paid too much tax in the past should consider whether the amount can be recovered with interest.

[1] Treaty of 29 March 1923 between Switzerland and Liechtenstein concerning the incorporation of the Principality of Liechtenstein into the Swiss customs territory (SR 0.631.112.514).
[2] Art. 7 para. 3 and Art. 10 para. 3 CISA in conjunction with Art. 5 para. 4 of the Collective Investment Schemes Ordinance of 22 November 2006 (CISO, SR 951.311) and Art. 4 para. 3 lets. b, e and f FIDLEG (SR 950.1).
[3] SFTA Circular No. 24 of 20 November 2017, Collective investment schemes as the subject of withholding tax and stamp duties, section 3.1.1.1 and Annex V.
[4] Ordinance of the Federal Department of Finance of 9 September 2025 on default and refund interest rates for duties, taxes and penalties (FDF Interest Rate Ordinance, SR 631.014), Art. 1 let. j and Art. 4. Refund interest rates: 4% in 2022 and 2023, 4.75% in 2024, 4.5% in 2025 and 4% from 2026.
[5] Federal Supreme Court judgments 2C_749/2017 and 2C_753/2017 of 20 March 2019 (proof of the exemption under Art. 17a para. 1 let. c SDA in the self-assessment procedure; securities turnover register under Art. 21 of the Stamp Duty Ordinance).

In its judgment 9C_463/2025 vom 17. Juni 2026, the Federal Supreme Court had to assess a case at the intersection of business succession, inheritance law and income tax. At the center stood the question of whether the transfer of shares worth more than CHF 8 million to a long-standing managing director on the basis of an inheritance agreement is subject not only to inheritance tax but also to income tax, which the Administrative Court of the Canton of Aargau denied. The Federal Supreme Court held that this assessment was, in any event, not arbitrary and dismissed the appeal of the cantonal tax administration.

I. BACKGROUND AND FACTS

The decision was based on the activity of A.A. for C. AG in the years 1991 to 2020, during which he acted as managing director, delegate of the board of directors and chairman of the board of directors. From 1999 until her death at the end of 2016, D. was the sole shareholder of C. AG and had no direct descendants.

In 2001, A.A. and D. concluded an agreement on the purchase of 585 registered shares at a deferred purchase price of CHF 1'392'300 as well as a publicly notarized inheritance agreement. It was recorded therein that all shares still owned by D. at the time of her death were to be transferred to A.A. At the same time, the inheritance agreement provided that the deferred purchase price for the shares would be waived.

Following the death of the testator, the Canton of Zurich levied inheritance tax of approximately CHF 3 million on the transfer of the shares in June 2019. The corresponding tax assessment was not challenged. A few months later, the municipality of residence of A.A. in the Canton of Aargau qualified the same share transfer as taxable income in the amount of approximately CHF 8.3 million and levied income tax thereon. Against this assessment, A.A. pursued the appeal process up to the Administrative Court of the Canton of Aargau, which followed his reasoning and did not qualify the transfer of the shares as a transaction subject to income tax. Against this assessment, the Cantonal Tax Administration of Aargau as well as the municipality of residence of A.A. lodged an appeal [1] with the Federal Supreme Court (“FSC”).

II. QUESTIONS OF DELIMITATION – AN OVERVIEW

A. Employee Shares as Employment Income

Employee shares are participations in the employer or in a company closely related to it which are granted to the employee on the basis of his employment relationship. Subject to income tax (and to social security contributions) is the difference between the market value and any acquisition price at the time of acquisition. In the case of blocked employee shares, the reduction in value resulting from the restriction on disposal is taken into account by way of a discount.

In addition to employee shares, the concept of employee participation also covers options and expectancies. These are in principle taxed only at the time of exercise or of accrual, with the result that, in the case of deferred acquisition rights, the tax base grows – in principle – along with the value of the company.

B. The Legacy as a Possible Alternative

The transfer of assets by way of inheritance, legacy or gift is subject neither to income tax nor to social security contributions. By means of a legacy, the testator confers an asset advantage on a beneficiary without appointing him as an heir. As in the case of a gift, the grant is made without consideration. Depending on the degree of relationship, the inheritance, the legacy or the gift may be subject to inheritance or gift tax.

Whether qualification as an employee participation or as an inheritance, legacy or gift is more favorable from a tax perspective must be examined in each individual case. Alongside the tariffs, which diverge considerably between the cantons – and which, in the case of succession outside the family by way of inheritance, legacy or gift, may reach up to 36 %, as in the Canton of Zurich – particular regard must be had to the special provisions on business succession which currently fourteen cantons provide for. These rules regularly also cover inheritance tax. Their practical significance lies precisely in succession outside the family, since direct descendants are in any event exempt from the tax in almost all cantons. The aforementioned special provisions provide for reductions of inheritance or gift tax of between 50% and 80%. [2] Some cantons even grant a full exemption. [3] 

These reductions or exemptions are, however, subject to the actual continuation of the business. The cantons make the relief conditional on a blocking period of typically five or ten years, throughout which the requirements – in particular the recipient's management position and the minimum shareholding of between 20 % and 51 %, depending on the canton – must continue to be met. If the period is not observed, the relief is subject to full or partial retrospective taxation, regardless of whether the recipient discontinues the business voluntarily or is forced to give it up.

C. The Reason for the Grant as a Criterion of Delimitation

According to case law, grants by third parties which have a close connection to an employment relationship do not necessarily constitute taxable income. [4] The FSC illustrates this with two examples: tips are not necessarily employment income despite an obvious connection to the employment relationship, and a collection of money by work colleagues on the occasion of an employee's departure is as a rule likely to constitute a gift. Even a grant by the employer is not excluded. In such a case, however, the character of remuneration must recede into the background.

Conversely, the absence of a contractual obligation to make the grant is not harmful: Long-service and anniversary gifts are also considered income from employment, even though there is no legal entitlement to them under the employment contract. The long-service gift does not compensate the work performed, but loyalty, and is therefore precisely not a gratuitous grant. Voluntariness is thus not a suitable criterion of delimitation; decisive is solely the economic, or deeper, reason for the grant.

III. THE ASSESSMENT IN THE CASE AT HAND

In the case at hand, the Administrative Court of the Canton of Aargau saw the deeper reason for the share transfer in the arrangement of the business succession and not in the compensation of the work performed. This was supported in particular by the fact that the transfer ultimately encompassed the entire company. In this context, the lower court held that, where more than 50 % of the voting rights are transferred, it must regularly be assumed that an orderly business succession constitutes the underlying motive for the grant. The FSC considered this assessment not to be arbitrary.

On the merits, the FSC considered that remuneration granted in addition to salary in the form of the entire company, which by its very nature can occur only once, appears extraordinary. Furthermore, the share transfer had not been dependent on the continuation of the employment relationship. Nor could the gratuitous nature of the grant, on its own, establish a sufficient connection to the employment relationship, since it corresponds precisely to the essence of a legacy. It was also of weight that there were no direct descendants or other heirs suitable for managing the company. It is true that A.A. came to be within the circle of potential successors in the first place on account of his long-standing activity for the company. However, this circumstance is of merely subordinate significance. Decisive in the FSC's assessment was therefore ultimately that, upon appraisal of the overall circumstances, the actual reason for the share transfer lay in securing the business succession.

IV. CONCLUSION AND GUIDANCE FOR PRACTICE

It follows from the judgment of the FSC presented above that not just any connection to the employment relationship suffices for an employee participation to be present. Rather, the employment relationship must constitute the actual economic reason for the share transfer. Decisive is therefore which motives underlie the transfer and whether these are predominantly rooted in the employment relationship or in a legal ground independent thereof, such as the securing of the business succession. It should be noted that the assessment of the FSC related to a question of fact, with the result that the court was limited to a mere review for arbitrariness.

Für die Gestaltungspraxis ergeben sich folgende Hinweise

  • Examination of the tax framework: Once a decision on the transfer of the company has been taken, the tax consequences under income tax as well as under inheritance and gift tax must be determined. The result should be appropriately taken into account in the concrete structuring of the business succession.
  • Clearly document the succession motive: It should be unambiguously recorded whether the transfer of the participation serves to arrange the business succession or whether it is to be qualified economically as remuneration for the employment relationship or for the work performed. The motive should then also be clearly discernible in the economic structuring of the transfer.
  • No link to the continuation of the employment relationship: Conditions of continued employment, forfeiture and retransfer clauses are the classic features of an employee participation. Every such tie is purchased at the price of tax risk. In the case assessed they were absent – and this was one of the decisive indications.
  • Review the cantonal succession relief provisions early in third-party successions: The exemption for close relatives does not apply here – which is precisely why this is the main field of application for the relief provisions available in fourteen cantons. The applicable law is that of the canton in which the deceased or donor was resident. The conditions – an active business operation, a management position held by the recipient, and a minimum shareholding of 20 % to 51 % – must be met at the time of transfer and can be prepared accordingly.
  • Obtain and review a ruling at an early stage: In the case of succession outside the family with a connection to an existing employment relationship, it is advisable to secure the tax qualification of the planned transfer at an early stage by means of a tax ruling. In particular, it should be examined whether the concrete structuring and documentation sufficiently clearly evidence the transfer motive.

[1]        Auf die Beschwerde der Wohngemeinde trat das Bundesgericht mangels Legitimation nicht ein (vgl. Urteil  BGer 9C_464/2025 vom 17. Juni 2026, E. 1.3.4).
[2]        Dies gilt für die Kantone Appenzell Ausserrhoden, Zürich, Waadt, St. Gallen, Tessin, Basel-Landschaft, Thurgau, und Graubünden, Glarus.
[3]        So namentlich die Kantone Jura, Nidwalden, Bern, Freiburg und Solothurn.
[4]        Vgl. hierzu und zum Folgenden: Urteile BGer 2C_703/2017 vom 15. März 2019 und 9C_604/2022 vom 1. Mai 2024.

It is settled case law that the Old-Age and Survivors’ Insurance (OASI/AHV) may recharacterize excessive dividends paid to shareholders working in the company as salary subject to contributions. As far as is apparent, the Federal Supreme Court had not yet ruled on whether an interposed holding company prevents such recharacterization. In its judgment 9C_532/2025 from 25. June 2026, the Court confirmed that it does not where the holding company essentially serves as a conduit. This article places the judgment in context, outlines its connection with the ongoing OASI 2030 reform and derives recommendations for practice.

I. SALARY OR DIVIDEND – THE STARTING POINT UNDER OASI LAW

OASI contributions are levied only on income from gainful activity, not on investment income. The same applies to disability insurance (IV), loss of earnings compensation (EO), unemployment insurance (ALV) and family allowance (FAK) contributions. For shareholder-managers it may therefore be attractive to pay themselves a low salary and high dividends – all the more so since dividends from qualifying participations have been only partially subject to income tax. The Federal Council estimates the resulting shortfall in OASI revenue at around CHF 43 million in 2009 and around CHF 182 million in 2018.[1]

The compensation offices (Ausgleichskassen), however, depart from the split between salary and dividend chosen by the company only where there is an obvious disproportion. Under settled case law, recharacterization requires cumulatively that the salary paid was inappropriately low compared with customary salaries in the sector and that an obviously excessive dividend exceeding 10% of the tax value of the participation was distributed.[2] The relevant reference is the capital employed, not merely the nominal share capital.[3] The Federal Supreme Court has maintained the cumulative test despite criticism. As the Federal Council also notes, a departure from it would be possible only by way of legislation.[4]

In advisory practice, the question regularly arose in this context whether the case law also applies where the dividends are paid not directly to the working shareholder but to a holding company controlled by him. Formally, the holding company is not an employee of the operating company. This is precisely where the new judgment comes in.

II. THE CASE: A MEDICAL PRACTICE COMPANY WITH AN INTERPOSED HOLDING COMPANY

In January 2017, a physician transferred his sole proprietorship into a company limited by shares (AG). In July 2017, he established a holding company in the form of a limited liability company (GmbH), likewise wholly owned by him, which acquired all shares in the AG on the same day. The physician worked full-time for the AG and drew a salary of CHF 86,040 in each of 2021 and 2022. Over the same period, the AG distributed dividends of CHF 582,000 (2021) and CHF 650,000 (2022) to the holding company.[5]

In the course of an employer audit, the audit office of the compensation offices found that the dividends exceeded 10% of the tax value. The compensation office then added the difference between the salary paid and a customary salary of around CHF 185,000 to the relevant salary (massgebender Lohn), totalling CHF 197,390 for both years. In the absence of specific provisions in OASI law, the Insurance Court of the Canton of St. Gallen applied the company law case law on piercing the corporate veil in liability matters by analogy. It held the structure chosen to be abusive and attributed the dividends received by the holding company to the physician as the beneficial owner.

III. THE REASONING OF THE FEDERAL SUPREME COURT

A. Piercing the corporate veil as a general legal principle

The appellant company did not dispute that dividends distributed via a holding company may also constitute relevant salary. It merely argued that the conditions for piercing the corporate veil were not met in the specific case. The Federal Supreme Court therefore did not need to examine in detail whether the case law on piercing the corporate veil applies by analogy under OASI law. It nevertheless added that, although the concept of piercing the corporate veil had been developed in connection with company law liability, it rests on a general legal principle. Accordingly, the legal independence of a company may exceptionally be disregarded where the separation between the company and its controlling shareholder constitutes a fiction that does not correspond to reality.[6]

B. Criteria for disregarding the holding company

The decisive factor was that the holding company did not carry on any substantial business activity of its own. 96.5% of its income derived from the participation in the AG, and it did not pay any salaries subject to OASI contributions. Moreover, the holding company took out a loan of just over CHF 650,000 from the AG and immediately granted the physician a loan of almost CHF 1.2 million. The funds thus largely flowed straight on to the beneficial owner, whether as dividends or as (possibly interest-free) loans.

The Federal Supreme Court did not accept the other purposes put forward by the appellant. The reference to succession planning had not been substantiated, and the purpose stated in the articles of association was not in itself meaningful. Given its very low net income, the management of an apartment building through the holding company did not amount to substantial business activity and did not make the structure chosen plausible. Rather, the main purpose of the holding company was to collect the investment income and pass it on to the sole owner.

C. Level of employment and level of salary

The Federal Supreme Court rejected as unsubstantiated the assertion that the physician had been employed only on a 50% basis. The lower court had convincingly shown that a practice with two physicians each working 50% would hardly employ a practice manager and seven medical practice assistants. In addition, the physician had previously earned an income of around half a million francs as a sole proprietor.

Noteworthy is a clarification in favour of shareholder-managers: a salary of CHF 172,080 for a full-time position as a physician would not in itself constitute an abuse of rights. However, the fact that the salary actually paid corresponded exactly to the income that, under the pension tables, entitles the insured person to the maximum full OASI pension could be treated as an indication that the OASI consequences had played a role in setting the salary. The appeal was dismissed.

IV. ASSESSMENT

A. A two-step test

The judgment results in a two-step test. The first step is to determine whether the dividends paid to the holding company are to be attributed to the working shareholder. This requires that, in the specific relationship, the legal independence of the holding company constitutes a fiction that does not correspond to reality. In the second step, the established cumulative criteria for recharacterization apply, namely an inappropriately low salary and a dividend exceeding 10% of the tax value. The holding company thus does not alter the substantive standard, but where it lacks substance it cannot have a shielding effect either.

Conversely, the judgment suggests that a holding company with its own substance and a comprehensible economic purpose cannot simply be disregarded. The Federal Supreme Court held the structure to be irrelevant not because of the holding company as such, but because of its specific conduit function and the lack of any substantiated other purpose. The practical line-drawing question thus shifts to the degree of economic independence required of the holding company. Which activities and purposes suffice for this – for example the management of several participations, the reinvestment of dividends, financing activities of its own or its own staff – is left open by the judgment.

B. Scope of the judgment

The judgment was rendered by a panel of three judges and is not intended for publication in the official collection. Moreover, the remarks on piercing the corporate veil were made in addition, as the appellant had not disputed the principle. Its practical significance should nevertheless not be underestimated. The Federal Social Insurance Office (FSIO) has included the judgment in its selection of case law on OASI contributions.[7] It is therefore to be expected that compensation offices and audit offices will in future specifically examine holding structures in the course of employer audits.

From a tax perspective, the flow of loans also deserves attention. Where a holding company serves as a mere conduit for shareholder loans, such loans may also be questioned for tax purposes from the perspective of simulated loans or hidden profit distributions. The judgment does not address this point.

V. OUTLOOK: OASI 2030 REFORM

In parallel, the legislator has taken action. In its report of October 2025, the Federal Council recommended examining whether part of obviously excessive dividends paid to working shareholders should be made subject to contributions without having to prove an unusually low salary.[8] The Federal Council took up this approach in the consultation on the OASI 2030 reform opened on 20 May 2026. Dividends are to be regarded as excessive to the extent that their yield exceeds 15% of the capital invested. The excess portion is to be treated as relevant salary.[9] The rule is to apply only to participations of at least 10% and to exclude one-off payments such as liquidation surpluses. The consultation period ran until 11 September 2026.

Such a rule would shift the current standard in two directions. The yield threshold would be higher than the current 10% limit applied in administrative practice, but the review of whether the salary is appropriate would no longer apply. For practice, it will be decisive whether and how the new rule captures distributions via interposed holding companies. Until it enters into force, the existing case law remains authoritative, supplemented by the considerations on piercing the corporate veil set out in the new judgment.

VI. CONCLUSION AND PRACTICAL CHECKLIST

A holding company offers no protection against OASI contributions on excessive dividends where it essentially serves to pass on investment income. The following basic rules can be derived for shareholder-managers with holding structures:

  • Set the salary at a level customary in the sector and document the basis for it. A salary set exactly at the income relevant for the maximum OASI pension may be treated as an indication that the salary was set with the OASI in mind.
  • Record the level of employment correctly and keep it consistent with the company’s staffing structure.
  • Give the holding company a recognisable function of its own and provide specific evidence of other purposes such as succession planning, rather than merely referring to the articles of association.
  • Do not pass dividends straight on to the shareholder by way of loans. Shareholder loans should bear interest at market rates, be repaid and be documented.
  • Monitor the dividend yield in relation to the tax value and keep track of developments in the OASI 2030 reform.

As at: 1 October 2026

[1] See Report of the Federal Council of 15 October 2025 in response to Postulate 22.4450 Herzog, Impact of the corporate tax reforms on the OASI contribution base (Auswirkungen der Unternehmenssteuerreformen auf das AHV-Beitragssubstrat).
[2] See BGE 141 V 634 and BGE 145 V 50.
[3] See BGE 134 V 297 (the so-called “Nidwalden practice”).
[4] See Report of the Federal Council of 15 October 2025.
[5] See Federal Supreme Court judgment 9C_532/2025 of 25 June 2026. Lower court: decision of the Insurance Court of the Canton of St. Gallen AHV 2025/3 of 4 August 2025.
[6] See BGE 151 III 361 consid. 5.4.3.2.1.
[7] See FSIO, Case law of the Federal Supreme Court on OASI contributions, FSIO selection No. 85.
[8] See Report of the Federal Council of 15 October 2025.
[9] See Federal Council press release of 20 May 2026, Federal Council opens consultation on the OASI 2030 reform.

In its decision 9C_296/2025 of 30 June 2026, a five-judge panel of the Federal Supreme Court addressed the relevance of the probabil-ity when recognising provisions. Intended for publication, the deci-sion establishes a clear threshold for individual risks and additionally requires an aggregate assessment where several risks exist. If the probability of occurrence of an individual risk is below 20% to 25%, an outflow of resources is considered unlikely. No provision may be recognised for that individual risk. Where several individual risks exist, however, it is necessary to assess the likelihood that at least one of them will materialise. If that aggregate probability exceeds the applicable threshold, a provision must be recognised. The Federal Supreme Court did not, though, specify the amount of the provi-sions.

I. BACKGROUND

The appellant construction company held a 35% interest in a consortium that had completed a major construction project with a contract value of approximately CHF 733 million. No outstanding defects existed when the project was handed over. However, warranty periods of three and five years respectively were still running.

The consortium identified 26 potential defects. The estimated probabilities of occurrence were predominantly between 5% and 10%. Only the item “other defects” was assigned a probability of 20%. The construction company recognised an expense of CHF 7 million for its share of an additional warranty-related provision of CHF 20 million.

The Tax Administration of the Canton of Bern refused to recognise the provision because of the low probabilities of the individual defects and an average probability of approximately 6.8%. The Administrative Court of the Canton of Bern upheld this assessment. The construction company appealed to the Federal Supreme Court, which partially upheld the appeal and referred the matter back to the lower court for reassessment. The issue was therefore whether the provision was commercially justified within the meaning of Art. 63 para. 1 let. a of the Federal Tax Act. Under accounting law, the recognition of provisions is governed by Art. 960e para. 2 Code of Obligations. Under the principle that the commercial accounts are authoritative for tax purposes, financial statements complying with commercial law are binding for tax purposes, provided that the provision recognised is commercially justified.

II. INDIVIDUAL RISK: NO PROVISION BELOW 20% TO 25%

For an individual risk, the Federal Supreme Court’s statement is unequivocal. A possible outflow of resources with a probability of occurrence below 20% to 25% is considered unlikely and does not justify a provision. At the same time, the Federal Supreme Court – once again – rejects the IFRS “more-likely-than-not” approach for Swiss accounting law, which is shaped by the principle of capital protection.

Above this range, the question turns to measurement. Prevailing academic opinion proposes a provision measured on a proportionate basis, at least in the lower probability range. Under this approach, the possible outflow is weighted by the probability. The Federal Supreme Court expressly leaves open whether this approach should apply.

III. MULTIPLE INDIVIDUAL RISKS: THE AGGREGATE RISK IS DECISIVE

For several risks that are individually unlikely, the Federal Supreme Court now expressly holds that a provision must be recognised if the probability that at least one of them will materialise exceeds the applicable threshold. The individual risks must therefore be assessed neither in isolation nor by reference to an average probability.

Assuming independent risks (the Federal Supreme Court does not address stochastic independence), the aggregate probability that at least one of several unlikely risks will materialise is calculated as the complement of the probability that none will materialise. Specifically, the probability that an individual risk will not materialise is 90% to 95% (100% less the probability that it will materialise). The probability that none will materialise is the product of these individual probabilities. In general terms, this can be expressed by the following formula:

With 26 independent risks, each having a 5% probability of occurrence, the probability that at least one will materialise is approximately 73.6%. Each individual risk falls below the threshold when viewed in isolation. The aggregate risk, however, is well above it. Based on this model calculation, the Federal Supreme Court’s reasoning would in principle require a provision. The Federal Supreme Court did not conclusively address how a provision should be measured where the aggregate risk is high. In the case at hand, the Court referred the matter back to the lower court for reassessment. The lower court must now calculate the aggregate risk in accordance with the Federal Supreme Court’s reasoning and determine the amount of the provision deductible for tax purposes.

IV. PRACTICAL RELEVANCE FOR SMES

Although the court’s decision explicitly concerns highly complex major construction projects, its central finding is also likely relevant to SMEs with several material contingent liabilities. The following simple example illustrates this point: just four independent risks, each with a 15% probability of occurrence, produce an aggregate probability of approximately 47.8%. This figure initially determines only that a provision must be recognised. It does not automatically mean that 47.8% of the maximum possible aggregate loss must be provided for. The Federal Supreme Court leaves precisely this measurement question open.

SMEs should therefore assess whether several individually unlikely warranty obligations, liability risks or pending legal disputes combine to form an aggregate risk requiring a provision. When preparing the annual financial statements, the following questions should therefore be assessed and documented:

• What obligations have arisen from past events?
• What are the respective probabilities of occurrence and possible outflows of resources?
• Are the risks independent, or do they overlap?
• What is the aggregate probability of occurrence?
• Which method is used to determine the amount of the provision?

Contemporaneous documentation is particularly important because the taxpayer must demonstrate that a tax-deductible provision is commercially justified, while documentation prepared only retrospectively may undermine credibility. The Federal Supreme Court expressly instructed the lower court to assess, from this perspective, whether the taxpayer company had complied with its duty to cooperate.

V. QUESTIONS LEFT OPEN BY THE DECISION

The Federal Supreme Court leaves open how the amount of the provision should be determined where the level of aggregate risk requires a provision to be recognised. It does not decide whether the proportionate provision proposed in the literature should apply. Nor does it prescribe a conclusive measurement method for the lower court. It does, however, once again reject the IFRS “more-likely-than-not” approach.

In addition, the formula set out above assumes that the individual risks are independent. However, the Federal Supreme Court’s decision does not explain how dependencies, overlaps or common causes among different risks should be considered. This issue is mathematically significant and will need to be addressed by the lower court in the remittal proceedings.

Finally, it remains open whether the aggregate assessment is limited to highly complex major projects or applies generally where several material contingent liabilities exist. In our view, SMEs should also take the new case law into account.

VI. CONCLUSION

Below a probability of occurrence of 20% to 25%, no provision may be recognised for an individual risk. Several such risks may nevertheless collectively trigger an obligation to recognise a provision. Probability therefore operates twice: first in determining whether a provision must be recognised and then in measuring its amount. In its landmark decision of 30 June 2026, the Federal Supreme Court established the principles governing the first question. It left open the subsequent question of the amount of the provision permissible for tax purposes.